A unanimous Supreme Court Thursday upheld on process grounds the previous FCC’s relaxation of several broadcast ownership rules (see 2101190070). This makes it unlikely that future challenges to quadrennial reviews will end up before the same panel of 3rd U.S Circuit Court of Appeals judges that has consistently ruled against QR orders for nearly two decades, experts noted in interviews. “The FCC’s decision to repeal or modify the three ownership rules was not arbitrary and capricious for purposes” of the Administrative Procedure Act, said the majority opinion by Justice Brett Kavanaugh. “We reverse the judgment of the" 3rd Circuit.
Acting FCC Chairwoman Jessica Rosenworcel is making moves that suggest she has high hopes of being named permanent chief. They include her plans for a top-to-bottom review of items before the agency and appointment of a press secretary. Rosenworcel replied to congressional letters sent to her and had an international telecom discussion. Her agenda focused on moving forward on items begun under then-Chairman Ajit Pai and acting to implement congressional broadband relief.
Congress, not courts, should decide net neutrality, said a federal judge Tuesday, ruling from the bench denying ISPs a preliminary injunction against California’s law (see our bulletin). “I don't find that the plaintiffs have demonstrated a likelihood of success on the merits at this stage of the litigation,” said Judge John Mendez on the motion by ACA Connects, CTIA, NCTA and USTelecom in case 2:18-cv-02684. This paves the way for the law to take effect, cheering fans of using Communications Act Title II to regulate broadband service, while industry plaintiffs agreed with the judge that Congress must step in.
The Supreme Court narrowly focused on questions of administrative law rather than diversity, judicial deference or legal jurisdiction during Tuesday’s oral argument for FCC and NAB appeals of the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals’ Prometheus IV decision. Broadcast and public interest attorneys were split about what that might portend.
Democrats’ apparent victories in runoffs for Georgia’s Senate seats likely smooth the way for the party to gain a majority on the FCC later this year and take Democrats' preferred course of action on net neutrality and other top-tier matters, officials and lobbyists said in interviews. The leads in both the two contests, if they hold, would leave the Senate split 50-50. Democrats would gain a majority after Jan. 20 with Vice President-elect Kamala Harris breaking ties. The FCC will be tied 2-2 once Chairman Ajit Pai leaves, raising questions about what the commission can get done before the Senate confirms President-elect Joe Biden’s eventual nominee to a third Democratic seat (see 2012090063).
Democrats’ apparent victories in runoffs for Georgia’s Senate seats likely smooth the way for the party to gain a majority on the FCC later this year and take Democrats' preferred course of action on net neutrality and other top-tier matters, officials and lobbyists said in interviews. The leads in both the two contests, if they hold, would leave the Senate split 50-50. Democrats would gain a majority after Jan. 20 with Vice President-elect Kamala Harris breaking ties. The FCC will be tied 2-2 once Chairman Ajit Pai leaves, raising questions about what the commission can get done before the Senate confirms President-elect Joe Biden’s eventual nominee to a third Democratic seat (see 2012090063).
Fox isn't getting its requested permanent waiver of the newspaper/broadcast cross-ownership rule (see 2010060032) that some critics feared the media company would receive in the waning days of the Trump administration. Instead, it got a temporary waiver to continue cross-ownership of WWOR-TV Secaucus, New Jersey, and the New York Post. The FCC Media Bureau order was issued late Friday afternoon (see 2012180069).
The upcoming shift to a 2-2 split FCC at the start of President-elect Joe Biden’s administration doesn’t necessarily have to mean total gridlock, as those opposed to Senate confirmation of Nathan Simington as commissioner are forecasting, officials and FCC observers told us. They do believe FCC Democrats’ ability to move on big-ticket policy priorities, like bringing back the rescinded 2015 net neutrality rules, will be hindered until the Senate confirms Biden’s to-be-named nominee for the seat held by Chairman Ajit Pai. The Senate confirmed Simington Tuesday with unanimous Republican support and similarly uniform Democratic opposition (see 2012080067).
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit rejected the National Lifeline Association’s request for emergency stay of the FCC Wireline Bureau increasing the minimum service standard to 4.5 GB a month (see 2011250064), said an order (in Pacer) Monday. The increase takes effect Tuesday, and Lifeline providers say it's an existential threat. The lack of a stay "is disappointing," said NaLA attorney John Heitmann of Kelley Drye. Judges Patricia Millett, Neomi Rao and Cornelia Pillard said petitioners NaLA and Assist Wireless “have not satisfied the stringent requirements for a stay.” Benton Institute for Broadband & Society Senior Counselor Andrew Schwartzman called that D.C. Circuit “boilerplate” for stay rejections. He called it a positive sign for NaLA that the judges requested an FCC response to NaLA’s request for a writ of mandamus compelling the agency to act on reconsideration petitions against a 2016 Lifeline order. "NaLA will continue to work on multiple fronts to preserve free access for Lifeline-eligible consumers to mobile broadband, including by seeking commission review of the bureau’s waiver order," Heitmann said. The timing of Heitmann’s application for review could influence how it's received at the FCC, attorneys said. The current commission doesn't have enough likely yes votes to advance a draft order on the Lifeline increase (see 2011160051). The change in the White House, Pai's stepping down next month (see 2011300032), and the possibility of prospective commissioner Nathan Simington replacing Commissioner Mike O’Rielly (see 2011240061) could change that dynamic, attorneys said.
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit rejected the National Lifeline Association’s request for emergency stay of the FCC Wireline Bureau increasing the minimum service standard to 4.5 GB a month (see 2011250064), said an order (in Pacer) Monday. The increase takes effect Tuesday, and Lifeline providers say it's an existential threat. The lack of a stay "is disappointing," said NaLA attorney John Heitmann of Kelley Drye. Judges Patricia Millett, Neomi Rao and Cornelia Pillard said petitioners NaLA and Assist Wireless “have not satisfied the stringent requirements for a stay.” Benton Institute for Broadband & Society Senior Counselor Andrew Schwartzman called that D.C. Circuit “boilerplate” for stay rejections. He called it a positive sign for NaLA that the judges requested an FCC response to NaLA’s request for a writ of mandamus compelling the agency to act on reconsideration petitions against a 2016 Lifeline order. "NaLA will continue to work on multiple fronts to preserve free access for Lifeline-eligible consumers to mobile broadband, including by seeking commission review of the bureau’s waiver order," Heitmann said. The timing of Heitmann’s application for review could influence how it's received at the FCC, attorneys said. The current commission doesn't have enough likely yes votes to advance a draft order on the Lifeline increase (see 2011160051). The change in the White House, Pai's stepping down next month (see 2011300032), and the possibility of prospective commissioner Nathan Simington replacing Commissioner Mike O’Rielly (see 2011240061) could change that dynamic, attorneys said.